Academic writing guide
9 mistakes that cost students the most marks
How to spot each one in your own draft and fix it, with templates, a 16-week dissertation plan and a rubric self-check you can use today.
Most lost marks have little to do with intelligence or effort. They come from process: the order you work in, how you frame the question, and what you check before you hand in.
Across assignments, research papers, journal articles and dissertations, the same nine mistakes appear again and again. Each section below shows what the mistake looks like, why markers penalise it, and a concrete fix you can apply to your current draft. Everything here is about building your own work and your own skills, so the grade you earn is one you can defend in a viva or a follow-up question.
Skim the headings, then spend your time on the two or three that sound most like you.
Mistake 1 of 9
Starting with a topic instead of a question
A topic gives you somewhere to read. A question gives you something to prove. Without a question, projects drift: you collect interesting material, then discover at the end that it does not add up to an argument.
Social media and mental health
How does daily Instagram use affect anxiety in 18 to 24 year old university students?
Keep narrowing until the question names a variable, a group and a context.
The fix
- Fill in the template: How does (or to what extent does) [factor] affect [outcome] in [group or context]?
- Run the one-sentence test. If you cannot answer it in a sentence, however tentatively, it is still too broad.
- Check it is answerable with the time, data and sources you actually have.
- Ask whether a reasonable person could disagree with your answer. If not, it is a fact, not an argument.
Quick test: a question that starts with “What is” often yields description. Questions that start with “How”, “Why” or “To what extent” push you towards analysis.
Mistake 2 of 9
Writing the introduction first
An introduction promises an argument. Until you have written the argument, you are guessing what you promised, and guesses show up as vague openings and a roadmap paragraph that does not match the chapters. Most experienced writers draft the introduction last and polish it after the conclusion.
Chips run in the order the reader meets them. The number shows when to write each one.
Reader starts hereReader finishes here
The fix
- Write a one-paragraph “working introduction” in week one to keep yourself pointed in the right direction, then replace it at the end.
- When the draft is complete, write the introduction in this order: context, problem, gap, your question, your approach, a short map of the chapters.
- Reread the conclusion and the introduction together. They should answer each other.
Mistake 3 of 9
Describing instead of arguing
Markers reward analysis and critical evaluation. A paragraph that summarises what sources say earns pass-level marks at best. Higher marks come from showing what the evidence means and why it matters for your question.
One invented example, climbing from description to argument. Aim for the top rung in every paragraph.
Smith (2020) surveyed 300 students about their phone use.
The study found that heavier night-time use was linked to shorter sleep.
This matters because sleep loss is the pathway most earlier studies on anxiety leave out.
Interventions should target night-time use specifically rather than total screen hours.
The fix
- After every paragraph, write “So what?” in the margin. If your next sentence would be a shrug, the paragraph is description.
- Make claims in your own voice at the start of a paragraph, then use sources as evidence for them. Sources should support you, not narrate for you.
- Use evaluative verbs: suggests, fails to account for, overlooks, strengthens, contradicts.
- Compare. Where two sources disagree, say why, and say which you find more convincing.
Mistake 4 of 9
A literature review that reads like a book report
“Smith says this. Jones says that. Lee says something else.” That structure lists sources but does not use them. A good review is organised by ideas, shows where scholars agree and disagree, and ends by pointing to the gap your project fills.
By source (weak)
- Paragraph on Smith (2020)
- Paragraph on Jones (2018)
- Paragraph on Lee (2021)
- …seven more paragraphs
- No link to your question
By theme (strong)
- Theme 1: how anxiety is measured (four sources compared)
- Theme 2: sleep as a possible pathway (three sources, one dissenting)
- Theme 3: student populations (two sources, both small samples)
- Gap: nobody studies night-time use in this group
The fix
- Build a simple matrix in a spreadsheet: sources down the side, themes across the top. Fill each cell with a few words.
- Each paragraph should be about an idea, citing two to four sources.
- Finish the chapter with a gap statement. A reliable pattern: “Although X has been studied extensively (A, B, C), little is known about Y in context Z. This study addresses that gap by…”
- Cut anything that does not help justify your question or your method.
Mistake 5 of 9
Weak signposting
Your reader is a marker with a stack of scripts. If they have to guess where an argument is going, they will guess against you. Signposting tells them where they are, why it matters and what comes next.
Use it as a default structure, then vary it once the habit is solid.
Section-level signposting
- Open each section with one sentence on what it will do: “This section compares three measures of anxiety to justify the choice made in Chapter 3.”
- Close each section with one sentence linking back to your thesis.
- Use headings that say something. “Findings” is a label. “Night-time use predicted anxiety more strongly than total hours” is a finding.
Mistake 6 of 9
Citing as an afterthought
Rebuilding a reference list the night before the deadline is where lost page numbers, mismatched years and accidental plagiarism come from. Referencing costs marks directly and puts your academic integrity record at risk.
The fix
- Use a reference manager from day one. Zotero is free and works with Word and Google Docs. Mendeley is a common alternative.
- Capture the full details when you read. Author, year, title, journal, volume, pages and DOI. Note page numbers for anything you might quote.
- Choose the style early. APA 7, Harvard, MLA, Chicago and Vancouver all differ. Check your department handbook rather than guessing.
- Run a two-way check at the end. Every in-text citation needs an entry in the reference list, and every entry must be cited somewhere in the text.
Paraphrasing is more than swapping words
Heavy night-time phone use was strongly connected with decreased sleep duration in the sample.
Students who used their phones late at night slept less, and the effect held across the whole sample (Smith, 2020).
To paraphrase properly, read the passage, close the source, explain the idea from memory in your own structure, then check you have not drifted from the meaning. Cite either way.
Mistake 7 of 9
Ignoring the marking rubric
The rubric is the closest thing to the exam paper you get in advance. Each criterion is a place where marks are won or lost, and the weighting tells you where to spend your time. Print it, pin it beside your screen and check your draft against it line by line before you submit.
Score your own draft from 1 (weak) to 4 (strong). The scores below are examples. Change them to match your work.
| Criterion | What a 4 looks like | Your score |
|---|---|---|
| Argument | A clear thesis that every section supports | |
| Evidence | Relevant, recent, well-chosen sources | |
| Structure | Logical flow with signposting between sections | |
| Criticality | Sources compared and evaluated, limitations acknowledged | |
| Referencing | Consistent style, every source matched both ways | |
| Presentation | Clean formatting, correct grammar, within word count |
Average 3.0 out of 4. Weakest: Structure, Criticality. Start your next editing pass there.
The fix
- Copy each criterion into a checklist and tick it only when you can point to the paragraph that satisfies it.
- Compare your draft against the top band’s wording, not just the pass band.
- Ask your tutor for a marked example if the department shares one. Seeing a real 70+ paper changes how you write.
Mistake 8 of 9
Editing while you write
Polishing sentences you may delete tomorrow is the most common way to lose a week. Writing and editing use different parts of your attention. Do them separately: write badly and quickly first, then edit in passes that zoom in from the whole document to single words.
1. Structure
Reverse outline. Move, merge or cut sections. Does the order serve the argument?
2. Argument
Is every claim supported? Any gaps in logic? Does each section answer the question?
3. Clarity
One idea per paragraph. Shorten long sentences. Cut filler like “very” and “in order to”.
4. Proofread
Spelling, grammar, formatting, references. Read it aloud, or change the font to see it fresh.
Mistake 9 of 9
Submitting without outside feedback
After weeks on one document, you read what you meant to write, not what is on the page. A second reader sees the missing step in your logic immediately. Even one round of feedback before submission usually improves a grade more than another day of solo polishing.
Who can give useful feedback
- Your supervisor or tutor. Use office hours and bring specific questions, not just “is this OK?”
- The university writing centre. Most offer free appointments and know the local marking culture.
- A peer. Swap sections with a classmate. Reading someone else’s work also sharpens your own.
- A professional editor or tutor. Useful for language, structure and clarity, as long as the ideas and writing remain yours.
Three questions that get better answers
- “In one sentence, what do you think my argument is?” (If they are wrong, your thesis is unclear.)
- “Where did you get lost or lose interest?”
- “Which paragraph is weakest, and why?”
Handling what comes back
Sort every comment into three piles: fix now, fix if time allows, and disagree. For the last pile, you do not have to accept the advice, but write a one-line reason for each so you are choosing rather than ignoring.
The 16-week dissertation plan
Mistakes 1 to 9 are easiest to avoid when the schedule leaves room for them. This plan suits a typical undergraduate or master’s dissertation. Compress or stretch it to match your deadline.
Referencing runs the whole way through, which is why it never becomes a last-night panic.
- Weeks 1 to 2: finalise the question, agree the proposal with your supervisor, set up Zotero and a folder system.
- Weeks 3 to 6: read, build the theme matrix, draft the literature review and a working introduction.
- Weeks 7 to 9: finalise methods, get any ethics approval, collect data.
- Weeks 10 to 13: analyse data and write up findings. Return to the literature review and update it based on what you found.
- Weeks 14 to 15: write the discussion and conclusion, then rewrite the introduction and write the abstract.
- Week 16: the four editing passes, a feedback round, then a final check against the rubric.
A rough guide only. Always check your department’s guidance and the marking rubric.
- Introduction800 words
- Literature review2,800 words
- Methods1,400 words
- Results2,400 words
- Discussion3,400 words
- Conclusion1,200 words
Final submission checklist
Tick these off before you upload. Your progress is saved in this browser.
Common questions
How many sources should a literature review have?
There is no universal number. For an undergraduate dissertation, 30 to 60 well-chosen sources is common, and for a master’s it is often more. Quality and relevance matter more than count. Check the guidance for your programme.
I am out of time. Which mistake should I fix first?
Fix the argument first (mistakes 1, 3 and 5), because structure and criticality carry the most marks. Next, do the referencing check and a single proofreading pass. Polishing sentences comes last.
Is it OK to use a tutor or editor?
Feedback on structure, clarity and language is a normal part of learning, and universities encourage it through writing centres. What matters is that the ideas, analysis and writing remain yours. Check your institution’s academic integrity policy for what help is allowed.
How do I stop procrastinating on the first draft?
Set a timer for 25 minutes and write without deleting anything. Start with the section you find easiest, not page one. A messy draft you can edit beats a perfect paragraph you never write.
Do these tips work for journal articles as well as dissertations?
Yes. Journal articles are shorter, so the question, the gap and the argument need to be even tighter. Check the target journal’s author guidelines for structure and word limits before you start.
Want more study guides and writing support?
We publish practical guides for students working on assignments, research papers, dissertations and journal articles. Visit our site for more.
Visit meet2share.comPublished by Educare Centre. This guide is general study advice. Always follow your institution’s own rules on referencing, word counts and academic integrity.